top of page

From Bank Vault to Cocktail Bar: The Reserve Key West

Writer: Zainya Zimmerer
Zainya Zimmerer
Oct 8
5 min read

Updated: Oct 27

By Zainya Zimmerer, Broker | Owner, Cayo Realty Key West


October 8, 2026


The next reason to stop at the old bank on Southard Street may be dinner and a cocktail.


The former Bank of America building at 510 Southard Street is getting a new life as The Reserve Key West, a planned gathering place for food, drinks and live music just off Duval. The project brings together four kitchens and three bars while keeping some of the details that make the building special.


And yes, that includes the bank vault.



Photo from The Reserve Key West facebook page. https://www.facebook.com/TheReserveKeyWest


What Will Be Inside The Reserve?


Owners J.C. Pernas and his wife, Patricia, envision a place where a group can settle in together and choose from different menus. Their announced plan calls for four kitchens run by local restaurant operators, with smaller versions of their existing concepts.


In a May 2026 interview, co-owner J.C. Pernas described plans for:


  • Spanish tapas

  • Seafood and oysters

  • Italian food

  • Sushi and Thai dishes


If you are wondering which restaurants have signed on, that part is still under wraps. As of October 8, The Reserve’s official website lists all four kitchens as “To Be Announced,” with menus still to come.


The owners have also described ordering from the different kitchens and the bar on one tab using a QR code, with counter ordering available as well. Early plans called for roughly 5,000 square feet and room for about 125 guests.


For anyone who has tried to get six friends to agree on one restaurant, the appeal is easy to understand. Someone can be in the mood for Italian, someone else can want sushi, and everyone can still spend the evening together.


A Rotating Bar, a Main Bar and the Original Vault


The banking theme continues through the three announced bars, each with its own place in the project.


The Exchange


One of the planned features is a rotating bar. Coverage of the project points to the Carousel Bar at Hotel Monteleone in New Orleans as an inspiration. It should give a familiar Key West address an unusual new way to enjoy a drink.


The Ledger


The main-floor bar will sit alongside the building’s historic mural, bringing one of the bank’s original artistic features into the new social space.


The Vault


The original bank vault is being planned as a speakeasy for cocktails and light bites. The Reserve says the original vault door will remain part of the setting.


The venue’s plans also include live music, smaller performances in The Vault and private events. That could make it a place to stay for the evening, with dinner, drinks and music all under one roof.


Before It Was Bank of America


One of the best things about an old Key West address is finding out what came before. At 510 Southard, the story reaches back beyond the bank many people remember.


A 1945 National Airlines timetable lists 510 Southard Street as the airline’s Key West ticket office. That was an earlier use of this address, before the present bank building.


By the early 1960s, First Federal Savings & Loan was doing business here. A February 10, 1963 advertisement in The Key West Citizen identifies the bank at 510 Southard Street.


The building later became Bank of America. Federal banking records show that a notice to close the Southard Street branch was received in May 2018.


U.S. Navy aerial photograph of the Thomas and Southard Street area in Key West on November 21, 1941.

The area around Thomas and Southard streets on November 21, 1941. This archival neighborhood view predates the present bank building. U.S. Navy photograph, Ida Woodward Barron Collection, Florida Keys Public Libraries / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.


The Mosaic Is Part of the Story


The vault is not the only piece of the bank’s past being carried forward. The interior tile mural is another feature worth looking for when The Reserve opens.


The Reserve identifies the mural as a 1962 work by Fran Williams Wagner and says it will remain in the venue. Her mosaics also reached places far beyond the Keys, including Miami International Airport and Rockefeller Center, according to the Lancaster Arts Hotel’s account of her work.


I love seeing an older building find a new purpose while keeping the details that give it character. A vault and a mosaic are the kinds of things that make a place feel connected to the island, even as something new moves in.


When Will The Reserve Open?


The Reserve currently advertises an October 2026 opening, although an exact opening day has not been announced on its website. The site is the best place to watch for the restaurant names, menus and opening updates.


Where: 510 Southard Street, between Duval and Simonton streets.



Questions and private events: hello@thereservekeywest.com



Opening information checked October 8, 2026. Confirm the latest details with the venue before planning your visit.


Another Reason to Keep Exploring Old Town


A neighborhood is more than the homes on its streets. It is the coffee stop around the corner, the place you meet friends for dinner and the familiar building you get to see come back to life.


If you are thinking about making Key West home, I would love to help you explore the neighborhoods and properties that fit the way you want to live. My Key West buying guide is a helpful place to start planning your move.



Your Key West Life Starts Here.


Other New Restaurants and Fresh Arrivals in Key West


While we wait for The Reserve’s doors to open, there are several other additions to put on your dining list. These include 2026 restaurant openings, a returning favorite at a new address and a new Old Town coffee stop.


Conchiglia


816 Duval Street | Coastal Italian


The former Croissants de France space has a new chapter. Conchiglia opened in February 2026, bringing handmade pasta and local seafood to a restored Conch house. The menu combines the owners’ connection to Italy with ingredients and a setting that belong in Key West.



Dragon & Rooster


626 Duval Street, at Angela | Pan-Asian


Opened in January 2026, Dragon & Rooster serves dishes such as ramen, pho and creative fried rice. Owner Scott Taylor, also of Kaya Island Eats, teamed up with executive chef Chris Gaskill on this small restaurant in the former Pho King Awesome space.



Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar


223 Petronia Street | Seafood and Raw Bar


A 2026 addition from the team behind The Docks on Stock Island, Fishwife brings seafood, raw bar selections and cocktails to Bahama Village. It is another stop to consider when you are in the mood for a seafood dinner on Petronia.


October visit note: The Key West Food Guide lists an October 14 reopening after a seasonal break. Check directly before heading over.



Doc’s on Duval


708 and 712 Duval Street | Barbecue, Southern Food and Seafood


Doc’s arrived in January 2026 with barbecue, Southern-style American dishes and seafood. Upstairs and downstairs spaces, a balcony overlooking Duval and live music give it the makings of an easy stop for a meal and a little people-watching.



Smokin’ Tuna Saloon


313 Duval Street | A Returning Favorite in a New Home


Smokin’ Tuna has returned in the former Hard Rock Cafe building at the Robert Curry Mansion. Live music, smoked tuna dip, conch fritters and seafood baskets are part of the familiar name’s new life on Duval.


313 Duval Street in 2012 while occupied by Hard Rock Cafe, before Smokin’ Tuna moved into the building.

313 Duval Street in 2012, when the building housed Hard Rock Cafe. Smokin’ Tuna has since moved into this address. Photo: qwesy qwesy / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0.



Baby’s Coffee in Old Town


518 Fleming Street | Coffee and Baked Goods


Baby’s Coffee now has a second location in Old Town, bringing a familiar Keys coffee name closer to home for downtown residents and visitors. Along with coffee and espresso drinks, the fall tourism update highlights baked goods. It is a new option for anyone who normally makes the trip to the original Mile Marker 15 shop.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page