top of page

Hurricane Season in Key West: Watching the Weather and Welcoming Busy Season

Writer: Zainya Zimmerer
Zainya Zimmerer
Oct 7
5 min read

Updated: Oct 27

Aerial view of Key West surrounded by blue and turquoise water

By Zainya Zimmerer, Broker | Owner, Cayo Realty Key West


There is a lot to look forward to in Key West right now. Fantasy Fest is coming, the snowbirds start returning, and we are heading into that time of year when it feels like there is something happening every day.

We are also moving toward the end of hurricane season. I still keep an eye on the weather, but I am getting excited about the busy months ahead and everything that brings people back to our little island.


How Hurricane Season Is Looking This Year

The Atlantic has had an unusually quiet 2026 hurricane season so far. We still have a few weeks to go, though. The season officially ends November 30, and October can bring storms worth watching.

In its 11 p.m. update on October 7, the National Weather Service in Key West said Isaias was not expected to threaten the Florida Keys. Locally, a coastal-flood statement remained in effect for unusually high tides and minor saltwater flooding in low areas.

I like following Mike’s Weather Page on Facebook for up-to-date information when there is something out there we might need to worry about. For official warnings and preparation advice, keep the National Hurricane Center, NWS Key West and Monroe County Emergency Management handy, too.



The Grotto and a Little Key West Faith

If you spend enough time around Key West, you will hear the story about Mary watching over the island from the grotto at the Basilica of Saint Mary Star of the Sea.

According to the church’s history, Sister Louis Gabriel helped bring the grotto to life after witnessing the devastation of earlier hurricanes. At its dedication in 1922, she is said to have expressed the belief that, as long as the grotto stood, “Key West would never experience the full brunt of a hurricane.”

It is one of those stories that is part of Key West. There is faith, history and a lot of love for this little island behind it. We can appreciate that tradition and still take the forecasts seriously.


Statue of Mary in the stone grotto at Saint Mary Star of the Sea in Key West

The Grotto of Lourdes at Saint Mary Star of the Sea. Photo: Tom Hambright / Florida Keys Public Libraries, CC BY 2.0. Image unaltered.


Hurricanes Key West Remembers

Key West has been through damaging storms, and water has caused some of our biggest problems. A hurricane does not have to pass directly over the island to push seawater into streets and homes.

Storm and date

What happened in Key West

Georges · September 25, 1998

Georges made landfall at Key West as a Category 2 hurricane, bringing wind and flood damage.

Wilma · October 24, 2005

Storm surge caused widespread flooding. Monroe County reports that about 60% of Key West houses flooded.

Irma · September 10, 2017

The county’s preliminary assessment for the City of Key West listed 282 homes with minor damage, 39 with major damage and 23 destroyed. Irma’s Category 4 Keys landfall was at Cudjoe Key.

Ian · September 27–28, 2022

NWS Key West’s preliminary report counted 93 residences flooded: 55 with minor damage and 38 with major damage.

These figures are for Key West, not the entire Keys. The Irma assessment also separately listed 11,625 homes as “affected.” The reports use different damage categories, so the numbers tell each storm’s story rather than provide a direct ranking.


Key West Hurricanes in Photos

You may recognize a few of these places. Click through the gallery for a look at Key West during and after past hurricanes, from Smathers Beach to Flagler Avenue and the waterfront.

  • Georges, September 1998: storm debris near Smathers Beach and Bertha Street

Georges, September 1998: storm debris near Smathers Beach and Bertha Street. Photo: William Hawthorne / Florida Keys Public Libraries. CC BY 2.0.

Dennis, July 9, 2005: waves wash over the waterfront at Truman Annex. Photo: Jim Brooks / U.S. Navy. Public domain, United States.

Wilma, October 24, 2005: flooding at Flagler Avenue and Bertha Street. Photo: Dale McDonald Collection / Florida Keys Public Libraries. CC BY 2.0.

Ian, September 28, 2022: flooding at Naval Air Station Key West. Photo: Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Nicholas V. Huynh / U.S. Navy. Public domain, United States.

Historical photographs are shown unaltered. The appearance of U.S. Department of War (DoW) visual information does not imply or constitute DoW endorsement.


How Key West Compares with the Rest of Florida

Hurricane impacts can look very different from one part of Florida to another. During Ian, Key West experienced damaging flooding, while the National Hurricane Center estimated peak flooding of 10 to 15 feet above ground on Fort Myers Beach and Estero Island.

For a longer view, NOAA’s historical comparison published in 2018 showed roughly eight years between hurricanes passing near Key West, six near Miami and nine near Tampa Bay. “Near” means within 50 nautical miles, about 58 miles. Those are historical averages, not a timetable or a prediction of damage to a home.

Where a storm goes, how large it is and how it pushes the water all matter. A quiet stretch is something to appreciate, while still being ready for the next forecast.


Our Reef and Those Beautiful Shallow Waters

The shallow flats and blue-green water are a big part of what people love about being here. Our reefs also help reduce the energy of incoming waves, which benefits the shoreline.

The reef’s distance from shore varies. Eastern Dry Rocks, for example, is about seven miles southeast of Key West. And alongside those shallow flats are much deeper channels. NOAA’s Coast Pilot describes harbor entrance channels 13 to 33 feet deep.

Calm water on a beautiful afternoon does not tell us what will happen during a hurricane. Reefs help with waves, but they cannot keep storm surge out. Shallow, gently sloping seabeds can actually help storm water build up along a coast.

There is another saying used here that is worth remembering: “Hide from the wind and run from the water.” Monroe County’s emergency management director uses it to explain why evacuation instructions matter so much in the Keys.


Sailboat on the water at sunset framed by palm fronds

The Excitement Is Beginning on Our Little Island

Key West even has a tradition of burning hurricane-warning flags at the end of the season. The celebration started in 2005, and yes, rum is involved. That sounds about right for Key West.

We are not quite at November 30 yet, but I am looking forward to everything coming up. Fantasy Fest, live music, outdoor events and familiar faces returning for the winter. This is when the calendar starts filling up and deciding what to do becomes part of the fun.

Whether you live here, spend your winters here or are planning your next visit, there is a lot to look forward to. The excitement is beginning on our little island, and I’m ready for it.



Thinking About Making Key West Home?

If you are coming down for the season and want to explore homes while you are here, I’m happy to help. Tell me what you are looking for, and we can talk through the neighborhoods and properties that fit the way you want to live. You can also start with my Key West buying guide for flood-zone and insurance questions to consider when buying a home here.



Zainya Zimmerer Broker | Owner, Cayo Realty Key West

Weather information as of October 8, 2026. Visit NWS Key West for the latest local forecast and alerts.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page